October 2, 2024

Stadium is attractive for investors? . . . don't think so!

It was rather a surprise to learn The Examiner Newspaper’s editorial had dredged up the pulp mill in the context of the proposed third stadium - the latest project that’s causing controversy in Tasmania. It was like being transported back in time when there was rarely a week without all three of the state’s dailies championing the pulp mill in some way, claiming it would be an economic boon.


The editor in this piece (published a few days ago) appeared to be following the same well-thumbed playbook. Together with, presumably, a lack of knowledge about recent Tasmanian history, he stated the stadium project had progressed too far, and it couldn’t (shouldn’t?) now be stopped. It prompted a letter to the paper – and a similar one to The Mercury since that newspaper is also principal stadium cheerleader, ignoring the fact that half the state neither wants it, and rightly believes we can’t afford it.  Sems it's a case of 'here we go again . .  '


“ONCE again Tasmanians are being told investors are lining up to financially support the proposed stadium, while according to a recent editorial, the project has progressed to the point of no return (The Examiner, September 19).


With the greatest respect, that is rubbish. Mr Thomson needs to study Tasmania’s recent history.

This same claim was used during the campaign against the Tamar Valley pulp mill. Several supposed Joint Venture Partners were always just a signature away from ‘investing’ in the pulp mill – until suddenly they weren’t.


All but one melted away into the shadows never to be heard from again, and that one soon departed after due diligence quickly showed the economics of the project didn’t stack up and community opposition was strong, sustained and vocal.


Potential stadium investors will doubtless also soon sniff out the amount of public controversy and opposition surrounding the project. And that the economics of the project don’t stack up.


Economist Saul Eslake made that very clear in his recent report. It should have been enough for the stadium to go the way of the pulp mill.


Tasmania has been treated to a sample of climate volatility recently, a reality that’s only likely to worsen.

Projects such as the stadium will inevitably be impacted. Disrupted travel plans, rising sea levels – which will make the Mac Point site rather vulnerable – and of course escalating global unrest and uncertainty that’s far more likely to result in people hunkering down and staying home.


These all add up to showing this is definitely not the time to be building a massive piece of infrastructure that Tasmania neither needs, and certainly can’t afford.”

 

 

 

 

Share this post on socials

Fracturing my wrist on Day One of NT trip was an unexpected and unwanted shock
By Anne Layton-Bennett July 19, 2025
Alice Springs usually gets a bad rap in the media. Some of it is probably justified, but my recent experience is a very different and more positive story. And I’m giving the medical team at the Alice Springs Hospital a very big and justly deserved shout-out as a result. A visit to the hospital certainly wasn’t on the itinerary of our recent NT tour. But the trip didn’t quite go according to plan. We booked this tour - that included Uluru, Kakadu, Alice Springs and Darwin – months ago, and long before there was the possibility of another state election so soon after the one held last year, which also involved heading to the polls twelve months early. But that’s by the by. Day One of the tour, which started at Uluru, involved a sunrise viewing of the iconic Rock. But while heading up to the viewing platform I stopped – a bit too suddenly maybe – to avoid intruding on the view of some chap taking a photo. I either slipped or skidded on the shaley path and fell badly. My left hand took the brunt of the fall, (my phone was in the other hand) resulting in a fractured wrist. Since I’m a leftie this was rather serious. It was also very painful. Back at the hotel Anna the tour director, ensured I was able to see the team at the small Yulara Medical Centre before we were due to head to Alice Springs. The medics there were great too, taking X-rays to send to Alice Springs hospital, and strapping my wrist up more securely. At Alice I was dropped off at the ED and yes, it was a lengthy and tedious wait – exacerbated to a degree by the fact we’d arrived on Territory Day – the one day in the year that NT folk are allowed to set off fireworks. And they do so with gusto, which always involves multiple injuries and a crowded ED. So while I was eventually seen by the medics the hour was advancing a lot and the decision was made for me to return at 6.30am the following morning so I could have surgery. This was deemed essential given I’m cack-handed, and I’m extremely grateful for that decision being made. Obviously I missed visiting the various things the rest of the group did that day, but fixing my wrist was much more important. Arguably it would have been more sensible to suggest I go to Outpatients rather than the ED, but that didn’t happen so the wait was considerably longer than it needed to be – and I certainly saw a slice of life I wouldn’t otherwise have seen, mostly involving Indigenous people and reinforcing some of the stereotypes we hear about in the media. But once it was all systems go, it really was and thanks to Lewis, Mitch, Prof Julian, Dr Ping and others whose names I cannot remember, for taking such care and making such an incredible job of the surgery to reset my poor wrist. Never let anyone say the care and professionalism of all the staff at Alice Springs Hospital was other than exemplary. It’s an opinion that was endorsed this week at Launceston’s Orthopaedic Clinic where the doctors who commented on my scar and the stitches (and more X-rays) were full of praise for surgery well done, when the temporary cast finally came off. Even so, with one of those removeable support contraptions taking the place of a cast, I still have four weeks of no driving, and some very careful and gentle exercises to do. Life can certainly be full of challenges, and this challenge was definitely neither wanted or expected, but it is what it is – while typing one-handed has become a new skill!
The story of the campaign to stop  Gunns Ltd building a pulp mill in the Tamar Valley.
By Anne Layton-Bennett June 8, 2025
Part memoir and part story of how a community came together and stopped a pulp mill being built in Tasmania's Tamar Valley.
Tasmanians stood up as one in opposition to an over-ambitious timber company - and won.
By Anne Layton-Bennett May 16, 2025
For 12 years Tasmanians steadfastly opposed the building of a pulp mill in the Tamar Valley. The campaign was long and hard and took its tioll, but the community won it. This book is their story.

Latest from my blog...